Sunday, November 15, 2026

Gaia Save Us! Not So Fast, part four. Gaia Burps!

This is the fourth in a series of essays about the Gaia Hypothesis.

I don’t mean burps like the one you just had. I mean, Gaia sometimes burps. I guess it depends on which way Gaia is facing. If she is facing the other way, it is not technically a burp.

This is number four in a series of essays about Gaia, which is the not-quite-alive not-quite-goddess system of feedback loops that keeps conditions on Earth stable, sort of.

These burps are methane burps. In shallow tropical seas, sediments accumulate with organic material. Sometimes this material becomes petroleum, but sometimes it becomes methane, or natural gas. When trapped inside of rock, natural gas can be extracted and used by humans. But when it is in loose sediments, as frequently happens in new deposits in shallow seas, it is simply held in place by the pressure of the water above it. Actually, the methane gas molecules are held inside of gels called clathrates created by water molecules.

Until one day when it isn’t, and the methane rushes out.

If the water becomes shallower, or less dense (due to global warming, for example), a critical point is reached when the first methane molecules begin to move, dislodging sediment particles, which allows other methane molecules to move…and before you know it you have a geyser of methane spewing out of the shallow water.

This is the explanation of the infamous Bermuda Triangle, which is an area of shallow sea between Bermuda and Florida. Pseudo-intellectuals such as the late Erich von Däniken imagined that it was outer space beings who made ships and planes disappear in the Bermuda Triangle, but it was actually just methane. Methane bubbles would disrupt the water and make ships sink, and the methane itself would displace the oxygen which the planes would need for combustion. Ships and planes would fall into the sediments without a trace.

Methane is a powerful greenhouse gas, much more potent than carbon dioxide. It will react with oxygen gas to become carbon dioxide, but this process takes about ten years. Meanwhile, the methane creates a powerful greenhouse effect. Much more important for the global climate is the slow release of methane bubbles from organic layers. You can see these bubbles in lakes over permafrost:

  

There were many shallow seas at the end of the Permian, and methane burps might have contributed to the general climatic chaos caused by the Siberian volcanoes and the surface area of Pangaea, especially as continents plowed through them on their apparently aimless course of drift.

Gaia has no mind and is slow. It may have saved Earth from becoming an ice planet or a hellish one, as explained in the first essay. But on a day to day, or million year to million year, basis, it is of little help to the planet.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Gaia Save Us! Not So Fast, part three. The Great Extinctions

 This is the third in a series of essays.

 One of the great insights of modern science has been that the ecosystem of the Earth as a whole might be self-regulating, that is, it regulates its systems (temperature, geology, atmospheric chemistry, biology) the way a body regulates itself. It adds a new dimension to the meaning of Mother Earth. This is an insight usually attributed to James Lovelock, who called the Earth Gaia, and extended by the late, great biologist Lynn Margulis. Neither one of them intended to imply that the Earth was a goddess; Lynn Margulis particularly told me so. Gaia is a self-regulating systems, not a goddess.

In this series of essays, I wish to explain that Earth has a regulatory system, which you can call Gaia if you like. But this system is very unresponsive except on the largest scales of time and space. Don’t trust Gaia to solve any of our current ecological problems.

This third essay is about how Gaia did not save us from mass extinctions. The previous essay was November 8.

You have heard about the event (the Terminal Cretaceous Event) that caused the dinosaurs (except birds, which are dinosaurs) to become extinct. Dinosaurs have caught everyone’s imagination, and even more dramatic is the fact that it was almost certainly a giant asteroid slamming into the Earth that caused the dinosaurs to die. Dinosaurs and an asteroid—it doesn’t get much more dramatic than that. Of course, the asteroid did not have to hit all the dinosaurs. It caused a massive firestorm that baked many of them, and thick smoke that brought years of darkness, freezing the survivors. Surely Gaia could not prevent asteroids from hitting the planet and cannot be faulted for the Cretaceous extinction.

But there was an earlier, much larger, extinction event, at the end of the Permian Period, about 250 million years ago. Although it did not involve an asteroid, it did involve one of the largest volcanic eruptions in Earth history, which poured lava over much of Siberia. It was a long, slow eruption. If you lived away from the eruption site, you might not have noticed anything on a day to day basis. But it did put a lot of sulfur dioxide into the upper atmosphere, which not only cooled the Earth but also poisoned the oceans, gradually.

The end of the Permian was also when all the continents crashed together to form the supercontinent Pangaea, which means the “whole earth.” This, in itself, would have made a major contribution to extinction, since many species live in shallow waters around the continents. One big continent has less shallow water around it than numerous, smaller continents. Also, to the extent that the climate was hospitable at the start of the Permian, it probably was not at the end. The middle of this giant continent of Pangaea, far from the coastal rains, would have been dry, much like the Gobi Desert today. Gaia has no control over continental movements, no more than over volcanic eruptions, which are both aspects of plate tectonics, and thus cannot be faulted for the Permian extinction.

A Gaia that cannot protect us from mass extinctions is of little help to the Earth. Gaia has no mind and is slow. It may have saved Earth from becoming an ice planet or a hellish one. But on a day to day, or million year to million year, basis, it is of little help to the planet.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Blue Wild Indigo, two. Lives Prepared for Disruptive Discoveries: Gil

Stan Rice has just published another novel Blue Wild Indigo in the series Under the Sun, which explores what, if anything, God is doing in this world under the sun: first, from the viewpoint of the poet who lived at the time of King Solomon, and wrote Ecclesiastes (Among the Lilies); next, from the viewpoint of the woman who loved the prophet Jeremiah (The Almond Branch); next, from Heloïse and Abélard in medieval France (Paraclete); finally, this novel, set in modern rural Oklahoma.

Here is the author’s summary from Amazon:

All her life, Sophia is inconvenient. She thinks too much and everybody knows it. She escapes twice from her Amish community in rural Oklahoma and discovers how dangerous and costly love and wisdom can be. The first time, she leaves with Clay. They find that the outside world is worse than their Amish community and they return, join church, and marry. Sophia’s second departure—with its risk of shunning—is not so easy. She takes refuge with Gil, a famous, lonely theologian, who is escaping his own past. But by hiding in Gil’s house, Sophia has exchanged one set of restrictions for another. Sophia’s brilliance shocks Gil into rethinking everything he thinks he knows, as he helps Sophia recreate herself. Their love grows as deeply as the roots of the blue wild indigo, a long-lived prairie flower. As Clay stalks Sophia, she and Gil discover that love is worth even the risk of death. Only after this experience are Sophia and Gil free.

This is how the novel begins:

Her eyes. It was her eyes that shot out at me, barbed me, and reeled me in. She made me feel like a fish who thought that because he understood the water he understood the world, only to find that he did not even understand the water. She left me flopping on the floor. Even now I do not know whether she intended to capture me or if I just blundered into the circle of her light.

 

Disruptions came to the lives of the principal characters, who have already been prepared for it. Both of their lives were fertile ground for the seeds of disruption to germinate.

Gil, a graduate student in theology (there actually are such people), was not expecting the world to be comfortable and orderly. Religion has spent millennia trying to explain (or explain away) why the world is so disorderly. But he was not expecting the intensity of the impact that Gloria would have upon him. Gloria, a short woman with flaming red hair, studied the greenest molecule in the world, chlorophyll. She not only knew a lot of science, but she had the zeal of a true scientist: she wanted to understand the world, in her case right from the first picoseconds during which light stimulated chlorophyll molecules to begin the process of photosynthesis. She was merciless with herself as a student, and with what she considered fuzzy thinking on Gil’s part. Gil said Gloria wanted to look at the minute details of the world, while he wanted to see the big picture. He said she looked at the world through a microscope, while he looked at it through a macroscope. Gloria thought macroscope was the stupidest word she ever heard. I suspect she was right. Despite this difference in attitude, each was exactly the person the other needed right then, and they became lovers.

The problem was, Gloria was not as smart as she wanted to be. She was a mediocre biochemistry student. She did not want to fail in her graduate program, so she decided to quit. She had the opportunity to leave biological sciences and move to agronomy, where she would study how to make photosynthesis increase crop yields. But she couldn’t even do this. She ended up taking a sales job with a pesticide company, which required intelligence way below, and paid money way above, anything she could have imagined. To Gloria, this was failure. I thought it was a heartbreakingly beautiful scene when she told Gil she was leaving: the red-haired woman played with a piece of broken green glass with the toe of her shoe.

Gil was also unable to get a big university job in theology. But he got a little job at a little fundamentalist college in eastern Oklahoma. His life is then disrupted by the discovery that this college, though it claimed to search for truth, actually was just a cookie-cutter for fundamentalist doctrine. But he could not just leave—jobs were scarce—because he met and married Lois, who turned out to be the grand-daughter of the college’s main financial supporter. This did not end well. Fortunately, Gil wrote a popular God-book that was immensely popular, so he could go, by himself, to live on a little farm in Oklahoma and just write books. He was just waiting for a disruption to happen.

In the next essay, the disruptions that Sophia experienced.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Blue Wild Indigo, a novel by Stan Rice. Part one: Disruptive Discoveries

 

Stan Rice has just published another novel Blue Wild Indigo in the series Under the Sun, which explores what, if anything, God is doing in this world under the sun: first, from the viewpoint of the poet who lived at the time of King Solomon, and wrote Ecclesiastes (Among the Lilies); next, from the viewpoint of the woman who loved the prophet Jeremiah (The Almond Branch); next, from Heloïse and Abélard in medieval France (Paraclete); finally, this novel, set in modern rural Oklahoma.

Here is the author’s summary from Amazon:

All her life, Sophia is inconvenient. She thinks too much and everybody knows it. She escapes twice from her Amish community in rural Oklahoma and discovers how dangerous and costly love and wisdom can be. The first time, she leaves with Clay. They find that the outside world is worse than their Amish community and they return, join church, and marry. Sophia’s second departure—with its risk of shunning—is not so easy. She takes refuge with Gil, a famous, lonely theologian, who is escaping his own past. But by hiding in Gil’s house, Sophia has exchanged one set of restrictions for another. Sophia’s brilliance shocks Gil into rethinking everything he thinks he knows, as he helps Sophia recreate herself. Their love grows as deeply as the roots of the blue wild indigo, a long-lived prairie flower. As Clay stalks Sophia, she and Gil discover that love is worth even the risk of death. Only after this experience are Sophia and Gil free.

This is how the novel begins:

Her eyes. It was her eyes that shot out at me, barbed me, and reeled me in. She made me feel like a fish who thought that because he understood the water he understood the world, only to find that he did not even understand the water. She left me flopping on the floor. Even now I do not know whether she intended to capture me or if I just blundered into the circle of her light.


This is a book for which the author chose not to seek commercial publication. The reason is obvious. There are thousands of works of fiction about the Amish, but almost all of them are written by Amish for Amish, which means the plot is almost the same for all of them: young Amish people experiment with the outside world, during their period of rumspringa, and find out that life is better back home. Almost nobody outside the Amish religion wants to read fiction about Amish, unless it depicts them as ignorant, backward, stupid people. But there is not even very much published fiction about this, because a reader grows weary of a writer that just heaps abuse upon people he or she considers boring.

What Rice has done is to write a novel about a brilliant, therefore inconvenient, Amish woman, who needs to leave her community even while she continues to love it.

The format of the book includes chapters written from first the viewpoint of Sophia, then of Gil, filling in their background stories—the stories that were too sensitive for them to actually tell one another about, so they wrote them down, often in the second person. The whole book has passages of very creative format. Chapter 4 of Part one consists of a shopping receipt, which reveals Gil’s mental struggles as he prepares for Sophia.

The first thing to note, regarding Sophia and Gil, the main characters, is that their meeting brings disruptive discoveries. Scientists and theologians alike must be ready for disruptions to come along. Perhaps Gil thought he was living in peace away from religious and academic strife in a country house, but he had all of his assumptions challenged when he met Sophia (from the Greek word for wisdom). She is a fiercely intelligent Amish woman, who grew up in central central Oklahoma. She had chosen a life (fundamentalism) that Gil assumed people only got forced into by their circumstances. And then, when she walked all night to find his house and simply assumed that he was going to let her move in with him. Two disruptions to his thinking. Gil assumed that the Amish were not too smart; but then again, natural selection favored their mild way of thinking, which spelled social and family success for them, so maybe it was an intelligent choice on their part. Sophia wandering into Gil’s life disrupted him forever.

But Sophia was not mindlessly fundamentalist. She chose her life after constantly challenging the assumptions of her family and church, about history and science. Church leaders know this is going to happen, and they allow a period of rumspringa in which Amish youths can try out the sinful world in order to find out for themselves that a life of family and church love is much better. But the running and springing around of rumspringa did not include freedom of thought. The young folks could smoke and drink, but they were not allowed to freely read or to go to college. Sophia had to go out into the world with her boyfriend Clay, and they both found out how the sinful world can degrade you.

Sophia experiences disruption when she, by chance, meets Gil. The more she does things with him, such as an environmental protest, the more she finds that her previous experiences have prepared her for him. She was already an environmentalist without realizing it. Organized environmentalism gives her a new purpose in her life. She finds a mental soul-mate in Gil and her life, also, is disrupted forever.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Gaia Save Us! Not So Fast, part two. Oxygen blast


This is the second in a series of essays about Gaia.

One of the great insights of modern science has been that the ecosystem of the Earth as a whole might be self-regulating, that is, it regulates its systems (temperature, geology, atmospheric chemistry, biology) the way a body regulates itself. It adds a new dimension to the meaning of Mother Earth. This is an insight usually attributed to James Lovelock, who called the Earth Gaia, and extended by the late, great biologist Lynn Margulis. Neither one of them intended to imply that the Earth was a goddess; Lynn Margulis particularly told me so. Gaia is a self-regulating systems, not a goddess.

In this series of essays, I wish to explain that Earth has a regulatory system, which you can call Gaia if you like. But this system is very unresponsive except on the largest scales of time and space. Don’t trust Gaia to solve any of our current ecological problems.

Perhaps Gaia is the reason Earth’s climate has been stable for over 500 million years? No, because the climate and atmosphere have not been stable.

The Earth has had five major extinctions (not counting the sixth, going on as we speak) and several minor extinctions. Gaia was, apparently, unable to prevent those from happening.

When plant life started covering the land surface, over 400 million years ago, photosynthesis increased dramatically, removing a lot of carbon dioxide from the air. Forests covered much of the land surface. These forests would not have looked like the thick modern tropical jungles; there was apparently space between the trees, making them more of a woodland than a forest. But there was an even more important difference between the forests 400 million years ago and today. Back then, when trees died, they fell into shallow water and piled up in mass graves, eventually becoming coal. Today, when trees die, they seldom form coal. Instead, they decompose. The reason appears to be that fungi, the most important modern decomposers of wood and other plant tissues, had not yet evolved the ability to digest wood. Coal—that is where the Carboniferous Period of Earth history got its name.

Photosynthesis removed a lot of carbon from the air, and it got stored underground in coal seams. Meanwhile, where did the photosynthetic oxygen go? Into the air, of course. Today, the air is about 21 percent oxygen; during the Carboniferous it got as high as 35 percent. If you had been there, you would have hyper-oxygenated. With that much oxygen, fires would have been widespread, even on wet plant tissue. Evidence from the fossil record suggests that this was what happened.

The oxygenated atmosphere was also very dense. That is why giant insects, such as giant dragonflies, which today would not have been able to get off the ground, could fly. Insects, moreover, breathe through little tubes in their abdomens. Today an arthropod that is too large could not breathe, because its breathing tube surface areas would not have grown as much as its metabolizing volume. There was so much oxygen that the giant dragonflies could fly and there were giant millipedes.

Gaia did not prevent this oxygen buildup, nor the removal of carbon dioxide which might have led to global cooling. Carbon dioxide was running out, and one of the evolutionary responses was that plants increased their carbon-absorbing surfaces: they evolved leaves for the first time, instead of just absorbing carbon through green stems. This only made the decline in atmospheric carbon more dramatic.

The oxygen buildup would not have occurred forever, because with too much oxygen, life would have risked extinction, including plant life, almost the sole source of oxygen in the atmosphere. In this way also, Gaia regulated the atmosphere, but only within very broad bounds, careening toward disaster without actually reaching it.

Gaia has no mind and is slow. It may have saved Earth from becoming an ice planet or a hellish one. But on a day to day, or million year to million year, basis, it is of little help to the planet.

Saturday, November 7, 2026

Gaia Save Us! Not So Fast, part one. Global warming

One of the great insights of modern science has been that the ecosystem of the Earth as a whole might be self-regulating, that is, it regulates its systems (temperature, geology, atmospheric chemistry, biology) the way a body regulates itself. It adds a new dimension to the meaning of Mother Earth. This is an insight usually attributed to James Lovelock, who called the Earth Gaia, and extended by the late, great biologist Lynn Margulis. Neither one of them intended to imply that the Earth was a goddess; Lynn Margulis particularly told me so. Gaia is a self-regulating systems, not a goddess.

In this series of essays (Gaia Save Us! Not So Fast), I wish to explain that Earth has a regulatory system, which you can call Gaia if you like. But this system is very unresponsive except on the largest scales of time and space. Don’t trust Gaia to solve any of our current ecological problems.

This essay is the first of the series: about global warming, which is nothing new in the history of the planet.

On an overall scale, the idea of Gaia seems to be correct. Currently, the Earth’s temperature remains relatively stable, because the atmosphere has just the right amount of carbon dioxide, which holds in the heat. That is, when there is too much carbon dioxide, Earth processes remove it from the atmosphere. Over a very long scale, the silicates in the minerals of the crust react with carbon dioxide, removing it from the air. This takes millions of years. On a shorter time scale, the photosynthesis of plants and the respiration of all organisms regulates carbon dioxide. These processes can react to changes in carbon dioxide, therefore global warming, in just a few centuries. If there is too much carbon dioxide, photosynthesis uses it up; if there is not enough, photosynthesis declines and respiration of all cells produces more carbon dioxide. Photosynthesis reduces global warming, respiration increases it, thus stabilizing the temperature, over the course of centuries.

Not only that, but billions of years ago when the Earth had atmospheric carbon dioxide levels thousands of times higher than at present, the sun just happened to be dimmer. The sun is the only source of warmth on our planet. In some way I do not understand, the sun grew brighter just as chemical and biological processes started removing carbon dioxide. Or perhaps the timing was just due to chance.

So far so good. Given enough centuries, photosynthesis will remove the excess carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. But we don’t have centuries. Global warming is already developing into a disaster (I originally wrote this during a French vague de chaleur, heat wave, which is becoming the new normal in the French summer). Whole areas of the Earth, currently home to millions of people, might become so hot as to be uninhabitable in a few decades. Meanwhile, Gaia seems to be still snoring, and is just waking up. It won’t get hot enough to kill the Earth—you can trust Gaia on this—but the Earth might get hot enough that human societies will not survive.

Still, it is conceivable that global warming might occur fast enough that the plants would not have time to recover, photosynthesize, and save us. Could the Earth become hot, forever, like Venus? When somebody in the audience mentioned this possibility to me, during a public lecture, I dismissed the idea right away. But maybe the guy had a point.

Another example of the failure of Gaia to save the Earth from temperature change is the exact opposite of global warming. During the middle of the Precambrian time, the Earth was covered with ice, apparently on three separate occasions. This has been called Snowball Earth. There was apparently more than one cause, but one of the causes was that the photosynthesis of single-celled algae in the oceans (there was not yet any life on land; there wasn’t yet even very much land) scrubbed carbon dioxide from the air so much that it led to global cooling. The Earth might have looked like an ice planet at those times. No one is sure if all of the tropical oceans froze over, but some of them did. Photosynthesis also filled the air with huge amounts of oxygen gas, regarding which there is also some evidence.

The reason the Earth did not slip into a permanently frozen state was because the crust of the Earth fractured into plates. Some of the plates started moving away from, and others toward, one another. At these plate junctures, known as fault lines, volcanoes frequently erupted, putting carbon dioxide back into the air and melting at least the nearby ice.

But it is conceivable that this might not have happened. Just a few fewer volcanoes along the fault lines, and the trajectory of the Earth toward being an eternal snowball might have been unstoppable.

I am thankful for Gaia, but it might not have saved us from unstoppable global warming or cooling. It was mainly luck.

But maybe, we think, Gaia might help us on shorter time scales. Gaia might not have prevented Snowball Earth, but it might be the reason that the Earth’s climate has been stable since life exploded in the oceans and later on land. Can we trust Gaia to maintain this kind of stability? I wouldn’t bet on it, as I explain in a later essay.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Paraclete, A Novel by Stan Rice, part two. Science in Pre-Scientific Days

 

This essay follows up on a previous essay about Stan Rice’s novel Paraclete, about Heloïse and Abélard in medieval France. The question I want to focus on in this essay is, Abélard was a priest and Heloïse a nun, but were they also scientists?

Abélard held most of the beliefs of his fellow scholars. He probably thought the Earth was fairly small and probably flat and looked mostly like Europe. This viewpoint is expressed in the crowning mechanical achievement of ancient times, the astrolabe, which looked like a big wristwatch and was used to keep track of the movement of stars, planets, and the moon. Heloïse and Abélard admired this invention so much that they named their love-child Astralabius after it.

Science, as we understand it today, was very uncommon and hidden before early modern times in Europe. Many textbooks have lists of early scientists, all male, with the acknowledgement that some of the Greek and Roman philosophers had started the process of science. As far as ancient and non-European scholarship was concerned, scholarly thought consisted largely of “I am the Great Conqueror, I say the world is flat, and if you disagree, your head will be on a platter.”

But the “scientific method” is more of an attitude, of seeking evidence to test our beliefs. Not just to confirm them, but to give these ideas a real chance to be wrong, and then if they pass the test, we can honestly believe them. People have always done this, and sometimes have gotten away with it. Greek philosophers such as Aristotle and Roman philosophers such as Lucretius even speculated about evolution, and they sought evidence for it. You can do science too, even though you may not consider yourself a scientist. See my book, Scientifically Thinking: How to Liberate Your Mind, Solve the World’s Problems, and Embrace the Beauty of Science.

In Abélard’s time, scholars were not allowed to disagree with church doctrine. What Abélard insisted on over and over and over was that scholars ought to be allowed at least to question the authoritative doctrines. Just ask about them, that’s all. This was an essential first step. If scholars ended up confirming the doctrines, then our ability to worship God would have been magnified. Whaddaya say to that, Uncle Fulbert? You afraid we might find evidence against those doctrines?