This is the fifth in a series of essays about Gaia.
One of the great insights of modern science has been that the ecosystem of the Earth as a whole might be self-regulating, that is, it regulates its systems (temperature, geology, atmospheric chemistry, biology) the way a body regulates itself. It adds a new dimension to the meaning of Mother Earth. This is an insight usually attributed to James Lovelock, who called the Earth Gaia, and extended by the late, great biologist Lynn Margulis. Neither one of them intended to imply that the Earth was a goddess; Lynn Margulis particularly told me so. Gaia is a self-regulating systems, not a goddess.
In this series of essays, I wish to explain that Earth has a regulatory system, which you can call Gaia if you like. But this system is very unresponsive except on the largest scales of time and space. Don’t trust Gaia to solve any of our current ecological problems.
This fifth essay is about how Gaia did not save us from recurring ice ages. For example, in the early part of the Cenozoic era, right after the asteroid, there was a lot of carbon dioxide in the air and the whole Earth was warm. Thanks to this huge greenhouse effect, trees grew right up to the North and South poles. But all of this tree growth (and algae in the sea) removed carbon dioxide and led to global cooling. The North and South polar regions were already the coolest parts of the Earth, since they receive the least sunlight. When global cooling occurred, ice began to form until Greenland and Antarctica had permanent ice caps. Permanent, until they recently started melting.
The ice age we are most familiar with is the one (actually there have been about twenty ice ages, of which four were important) that just ended. For the last two million years, during the Pleistocene epoch, the Earth has experienced a series of ice ages which have disrupted the equilibrium of life in the northern hemisphere.
The explanation usually given for the Pleistocene ice ages (see, for example, my Encyclopedia of Evolution) is the Milanković cycles, in which the Earth goes around the sun while spinning like a top. The angle of the spin and the proximity to the sun causes summers to be cold in the northern hemisphere about every 100,000 years, which begins a new ice age when glaciers plow their way southward. When the northern summers are warmer, the glaciers melt. But as I understand it, there have always been Milanković cycles, even before the recent recurring ice ages. Why did ice ages not occur during the time of the dinosaurs? (Well, maybe they did, but they had a very small effect.)
Before about three million years ago, a massive ocean current carried warm water from tropical regions through the Atlantic Ocean into the Arctic Ocean, keeping it warmer than it is today. Trees used to grow right up to near the North Pole 50 million years ago. This current was the great granddaddy of today’s Gulf Stream. But about three million years ago, North and South America joined together by continental drift, forming the isthmus of Panama. The now relatively feeble Gulf Stream could not prevent the recurring glaciations.
An interesting question is, why did the Milanković cycles not produce ice ages earlier in Earth history? This never happened to the dinosaurs, did it? Well, of course, we cannot know. But the reason might have been global warming which, for the dinosaurs, was a good thing. Through much of Earth history, carbon dioxide stayed around 3000 parts per million, compared to just over 400 today. The Earth was a greenhouse. The slight changes in sunlight intensity, caused by the Milanković cycles, did not noticeably affect the climate. Or did they? They might have caused cycles, not of ice, but of rainfall. During periods of high rainfall, fresh water might have formed a layer over salt water just offshore, causing the deep, saline water to be anaerobic and turn black. This might explain the Mesozoic black shale formations.
The only way Gaia could have prevented the ice ages would have been to manipulate the movement of continents which, as far as anyone can tell, it does not do. Gaia has no mind and is slow. It may have saved Earth from becoming an ice planet or a hellish one. But on a day to day, or million year to million year, basis, it is of little help to the planet.


