Every
human being who has ever lived (except, Christians claim, Jesus) has sinned. We
all know this is true, even though we cannot easily define sin. Every culture
group, race, and country consists of people all of whom have sinned, many of
them in a spectacularly evil fashion. There is no group from which we cannot
find a long list of atrocities, from prehistory to the present.
But
whites have committed atrocities way out of proportion to their numerical
importance in human history, and in human culture today. The example I will
examine now is slavery. Every cultural group has had slaves, primarily from
among captives from other social groups. But whites have had more slaves,
treated them worse, and continue to honor the tradition of slavery, more than
any other group.
Take,
for example, black slavery in the southern colonies, later the southern states.
(These thoughts have been inspired by reading Geraldine Brooks’s novel Horse.)
The main reason that southern whites started buying black slaves was that they
had killed most of the Native American slaves. Native slaves were cheaper, but
they were mostly dead by about the year 1600. So the whites bought slaves from
Africa who were captured from their tribes and transported as cheaply as
possible (tied up in their own filth in slave ships) to the South. The shrewd
slave traders took into their calculations that many of their captives would
die while on board.
The
Southerners treated their slaves much more cruelly than was necessary or even
profitable. The slaveowner men would force not just work but also sex on their
slaves. I remember an exhibit of slave artifacts in a museum in Tulsa (which is
the reddest red state, but museums everywhere tend to be progressive) that
showed a bill of sale for slaves. A 45-year-old man went for about $50, while a
seventeen-year-old girl went for $600. What did the girl have that made her
twelve times as valuable? Sexuality, that’s what. Not only was it legal rape,
but it was the way that plantation owners could keep up their slave populations
without having to import more of them, which was theoretically illegal after
1808.
The
owners would force the slaves to do whatever they chose, regardless of the
strengths and talents of the slaves. In Brooks’s novel, a very skillful slave
horse trainer was forced to work in the fields while inept white trainers
allowed a champion racehorse to be injured. If slaves were an investment,
southern white enjoyed abusing their investments in a stupid fashion. Few slave
owners would permit slaves to learn to read and write; illiterate whites would
look down upon even the free blacks who could read.
Not
only that, but the white slave owners would take credit for any innovations or
improvements in land and property that the slaves came up with.
In
some cases, southern whites were nearly crazy with their lust for cruelty. A
prime example was the Confederate terrorist William Quantrill,
who exulted in cruelty not only against blacks but against any whites he
suspected of not being racist enough. He is one of the characters in Brooks’s
novel.
Whites
would find or create opportunities to insult and injure even free blacks, that
is, the few that were allowed to purchase their freedom. Any black person could
be arrested and detained until their status as a free black could be
established. This may sound uncomfortably like ICE detaining anyone they
suspect of being in America illegally, but at least ICE once in a while allows
claims of legitimate presence in America to be investigated.
Slaves
were considered property of their white owners, but they treated their slaves
worse than they would have treated any of their other property, whether mules
or saddles. In some cases, they enjoyed torturing their slaves.
White
racists try to use the imperfection of blacks as an excuse for past slavery and
ongoing cruelty. A vendor of Confederate flags, at a roadside market in
Oklahoma, told me that it was the blacks who began enslaving other blacks,
that’s how the slave trade got started. But who was the market? When I told him
that what he was doing was offensive, he called the sheriff, but I got away
before being arrested. No, this was not back in the 1960s. This was about 2015.
I
am Cherokee. Some of my ancestors owned slaves. But our collective Native guilt
is far less than that of southern whites.
What
about northern whites in America? Some northern whites, and some Europeans,
profited from black slavery, but the entire southern American culture was based
upon it.
I
did not contribute to any of this. I am not responsible for the sins of my
ancestors. But part of my white privilege has resulted from the oppressions of
the past. Maybe nothing can be done about it now, but when I look a person of
color in the eye I feel a level of guilt that goes beyond the calculus of legal
liability. I cannot simply pretend that it is not there.
White
guilt is a heavy burden, but the only people who feel it are those who, like
myself, are trying very hard to live in a redemptive fashion and contribute to
a fair and just society. I love people of color (with a few individual
exceptions) even if they do not, and cannot, know it. In contrast, racists do
not feel any guilt.
The
burden of white guilt continues today. In Brooks’s novel, the
twenty-first-century black protagonist gets shot by police who assumed, at a
glance, that he was a criminal. His white friend was very upset by this, but
his black friends said he should have expected it. If a black man sees police,
he should just assume that he is likely to be shot. I hate to admit that this
is true.
The
black protagonist from the nineteenth century in Brooks’s novel chose to live
in Canada, and explained why: even after emancipation, he could feel white
hatred all around him.
I
live in France. I am embarrassed to be an American right now, with unabashed
racists in charge of the country of which I am a citizen. I am always instantly
ready with an apology on behalf of my country. What can I say to the Lebanese
woman in my French language class, whose cousin was just killed by an Israeli,
or American, bomb? I can see in her eyes that she does not blame me, but I have
to go further and assure her of my sympathy, and that I do not support Trump’s
war, nor was I or American citizens in general consulted before He chose to
start it as if He is God who can decide everyone’s fate.